A lot of the people think that the last two were worse than the ones before, but personally I don’t see the problem with them. Heretics is probably my favorite Dune book, with chapterhouse and god-emperor as close seconds. Anybody else have thoughts?
Also
spoiler
B E E F S W E L L I N G
I love them. The weirdness. The Miles Teg speed thing. I really wish Frank had managed to continue to tell the story.
Yeah, shit got weird but I’m.into it.
Never build a big building without planting the trees for the replacement beams.
I really enjoyed them… the middle of the series kinda dragged on. These two booked showed a very interesting evolution of the universe.
I love them. The speed mutation. The inner dealings of the mysterious Bene Gesserit. Wish there were more along those lines.
I’ve only read the first book and didn’t like it very much. How different are the other 5 Dune books? Are they still primarily focused on the characters? I’d really like them to talk a bit more about the technology of the world and why things are the way they are.
The original series eventually delves more deeply into why the society and technology is in the state we see it during the books, but it’s a gradual shift. Character focus remains the main theme throughout.
You might enjoy some of the “prequel” books written by his son, Brian, and Kevin J. Anderson (allegedly based… perhaps loosely… on Frank’s unpublished notes). They tend to focus more on the setting as a whole. Personally I’m not a fan of the actual writing, but there’s a ton of lore crammed into them.
The first book has by far the most conventional plot. In many ways it has the shape of a heroic journey which is conventionally digestible alongside all of the quirks of the Dune universe.
The follow up books discuss why putting all of your hopes into a heroic leader is a terrible idea. Paul is considered a failure by the books, and his son’s journey to being a leader and what exactly he means to accomplish gets weird. (In a dense and to many, highly enjoyable way).
Personally, I feel like the books deal more with how people interact and behave in a future environment. Maybe Brian(the author’s son)'s prequels deal with that better, but some people hate them.
I really enjoy them too. I feel like Herbert took the series to a woeid but intuitive place via those novels. I think some people forget that there are huge chronological gaps between the earlier novels and God-Emperor onwards. So there will naturally be character continuity issues. But Herbert handled them well. My only complaint is the abrupt and weird ending for Chapterhouse. But Herbert couldn’t control his own death, so that’s understandable.
Also, heads up that we have a community on Lemmy that’s dedicated to Dune material (novels, movies, etc.) - [email protected]
Edit: fixed the link.
Hi there! Looks like you linked to a Lemmy community using a URL instead of its name, which doesn’t work well for people on different instances. Try fixing it like this: [email protected]
